IIA-CIA-PART3 practice question 34 of 35

The internal auditor concluded there was a high likelihood that a significant wind farm development, worth $200 million, would be delayed from its approved schedule. As a result, electricity production would not start on time, leading to considerable financial penalties. Which of the following should be added to the observation to support its clarity and completeness?

Full set: 516 questions
Answer options
A: The effect of the observation
B: The criteria of the observation
C: The condition of the observation
D: The cause of the observation Correct answer
Correct Answer:
D. The cause of the observation
Explanation

A well-structured audit observation contains four key elements: Criteria, Condition, Cause, and Effect. The provided scenario clearly states the Condition (a likely delay in the project) and the Effect (financial penalties). However, it omits the Cause—the reason why the project is likely to be delayed. Identifying the root cause is critical for developing a meaningful and effective recommendation to address the problem. Adding the cause would provide the necessary context for management to understand and correct the issue.

Why Incorrect

A. The effect is already stated: "leading to considerable financial penalties."
B. The criteria (the standard or expectation) is implied by the "approved schedule."
C. The condition (the current state or problem) is clearly identified as the "high likelihood" of a delay.

References

- The Institute of Internal Auditors (IIA). (2017). Practice Guide: Audit Reports: Communicating Audit Results. This guide details the components of an effective audit finding, emphasizing that well-developed observations include the criteria, condition, cause, and effect to be persuasive and actionable.

- Pickett, K. H. S. (2019). The Internal Audit Handbook (4th ed.). Wiley. Chapter 16, "Audit reporting," discusses the elements of a finding, noting that the cause explains why the condition exists and is essential for developing recommendations.

Scroll to Top