IIA-CRMA practice question 31 of 35

An internal auditor is reviewing employee travel data to identify opportunities to cut costs while ensuring adequate participation at conferences to support the organization's mission. Which of the following pieces of evidence would be sufficient for completing this task?

Full set: 283 questions

Domain Risk Management Assurance

Answer options
A: A log from the last year that includes dates of travel, conference titles, and conference objectives, all of which correspond with employee names and costs per trip. Correct answer
B: A log that includes titles of conferences that all employees were invited to attend in the last year, along with the dates of those conferences and average costs per traveler.
C: A log of conferences titles, dates of travel for each employee, and a detailed summary of conference objectives and how they relate to the organization's mission needs.
D: A log of employee travel requests, which include the title of each conference, the conference objectives, anticipated dates of travel, and estimated costs.
Correct Answer:
A. A log from the last year that includes dates of travel, conference titles, and conference objectives, all of which correspond with employee names and costs per trip.
Explanation

To achieve the dual objectives of cutting costs and ensuring mission alignment, the auditor requires sufficient, reliable, and relevant evidence. Option A provides the most complete dataset for this task. It includes actual "costs per trip," which is essential for cost-cutting analysis, and "conference objectives" linked to specific employees and events, which is necessary to evaluate alignment with the organization's mission. This combination of actual financial data with programmatic details from a completed period ("last year") constitutes sufficient evidence to form a well-supported conclusion, as mandated by auditing standards.

Why Incorrect

B. This log is insufficient as it is based on invitations, not actual attendance, and uses average costs, which are not reliable for detailed cost analysis.
C. This option completely lacks any cost data, making it impossible for the auditor to address the objective of identifying opportunities to cut costs.
D. This log is unreliable for the review because it contains estimated costs and unconfirmed travel requests, not actual expenditures and completed trips.

References

1. The Institute of Internal Auditors (IIA), International Standards for the Professional Practice of Internal Auditing (Standards), 2017.

Standard 2310: Identifying Information: "Internal auditors must identify sufficient, reliable, relevant, and useful information to achieve the engagement’s objectives." Option A provides information that meets all four criteria for the stated objectives, whereas the other options fail on one or more.

2. The Institute of Internal Auditors (IIA), Implementation Guide 2310: Identifying Information, July 2020.

Section: "Sufficient Information" and "Relevant Information" (pp. 2-3): The guide clarifies that sufficiency relates to the quantity of evidence and relevance pertains to the relationship between the information and the engagement objectives. Option A is the only choice that provides sufficient and relevant information for both the cost-cutting and mission-alignment objectives.

3. Arens, A. A., Elder, R. J., Beasley, M. S., & Hogan, C. E. (2020). Auditing and Assurance Services: An Integrated Approach (17th ed.). Pearson.

Chapter 7, "Audit Evidence," Section on "Sufficiency and Appropriateness": This university-level textbook explains that audit evidence must be persuasive. Persuasiveness depends on appropriateness (relevance and reliability) and sufficiency. Evidence from actual, completed transactions (Option A) is more reliable than estimates or requests (Option D) and more relevant than data on invitations (Option B).

Scroll to Top