IIA-CRMA practice question 27 of 35

An organization invests its savings in a volatile stock with the potential for high gains rather than a mutual fund with a lower expected return and lower volatility. This best describes which of the following risk concepts?

Full set: 283 questions

Domain Risk Management Governance

Answer options
A: Risk identification.
B: Risk appetite.
C: Risk capacity.
D: Risk tolerance. Correct answer
Correct Answer:
D. Risk tolerance.
Explanation

The scenario describes an organization's willingness to accept a significant level of variation (high volatility) in the performance of a specific investment to achieve a particular objective (high gains). This is the definition of risk tolerance. Risk tolerance operationalizes risk appetite by setting acceptable levels of deviation from objectives. The choice to invest in a volatile stock, rather than a more stable mutual fund, demonstrates a high tolerance for the specific risks associated with that investment strategy.

Why Incorrect

A. Risk identification: This is the process of finding and describing risks. The scenario describes a decision made after risks were likely already identified, not the identification process itself.
B. Risk appetite: This is a broader, high-level statement about the amount of risk an organization is willing to accept to achieve its strategy. Risk tolerance is the more specific application of appetite to a particular objective, as depicted in the scenario.
C. Risk capacity: This refers to the maximum amount of risk an organization can absorb without failing. The scenario describes a strategic choice (willingness), not the organization's maximum limit (ability).

References

1. COSO, Enterprise Risk Management — Integrating with Strategy and Performance. (June 2017).

Page 7, 39: Defines risk tolerance as "The acceptable variation in performance... It is the range of acceptable outcomes related to achieving a business objective." The example of choosing a volatile stock for high gains directly illustrates accepting a wide variation in performance to meet an objective.

Page 38: Distinguishes risk appetite as the broad amount of risk an entity is willing to accept, while tolerance is the specific variation related to performance targets.

2. The Institute of Internal Auditors (IIA), Leveraging COSO Across the Three Lines of Defense. (July 2015).

Page 10: States, "Risk tolerance, in the context of the COSO Framework, reflects the acceptable variation in outcomes related to specific performance measures linked to the achievement of objectives." This directly supports that the investment choice, tied to a performance goal, is an expression of risk tolerance.

3. Pickett, K. H. Spencer. The Internal Auditing Handbook. 3rd ed., John Wiley & Sons, 2010.

Chapter 11, Section "Risk Appetite and Tolerance," Page 268: Explains that "Risk tolerance is the application of risk appetite to specific objectives... For example, the board may have an appetite for a certain level of risk in its investment portfolio, but it may only tolerate a small chance of a negative return." The question's scenario is a direct example of this principle.

Scroll to Top