INTEGRATED-PHYSICAL-SCIENCES practice question 3 of 15

Which question would be appropriate for an observational study?

Full set: 70 questions

Domain The Nature of Science

Answer options
A: How does the mass of a toy car affect how fast it rolls down a track?
B: What is the brightest star that can be seen from Earth? Correct answer
C: Which type of glass best resists scratching?
D: Which type of rock dissolves fastest when exposed to acid rain?
Correct Answer:
B. What is the brightest star that can be seen from Earth?
Explanation

An observational study involves a researcher observing subjects and measuring variables of interest without assigning treatments or manipulating the environment. The goal is to describe a group or situation. Determining the brightest star seen from Earth requires an astronomer to observe celestial bodies in their natural state and measure their apparent magnitude. The researcher cannot control or alter the stars' intrinsic brightness or distance. This passive data collection on a naturally occurring phenomenon is the hallmark of an observational study.

Why Incorrect

A: This is an experimental study because the researcher would manipulate an independent variable (the mass of the car) to observe its effect on a dependent variable (speed). C: This is an experimental study as it requires a controlled test where different glass types are subjected to a standardized scratching force to compare their resistance. D: This is an experimental study because it involves actively exposing different rock types (the independent variable) to acid to measure and compare their dissolution rates. ---

References

1. University of California, Berkeley, Department of Statistics. "Data 8: The Foundations of Data Science, Chapter 2: Causality and Experiments." This chapter distinguishes between observational studies and randomized controlled experiments, noting that in an observational study, "the researcher has no control over the variables... they just observe what happens." Astronomy is provided as a classic example of an observational science. (Available at: https://www.inferentialthinking.com/chapters/02/causality-and-experiments.html, Section 2.1)

2. MIT OpenCourseWare. "8.282J / 12.402J Introduction to Astronomy, Spring 2006." The course syllabus and lecture notes describe the practice of astronomy as fundamentally observational, relying on the collection of light and other radiation from celestial objects to deduce their properties and behaviors without direct manipulation. (Available at: https://ocw.mit.edu/courses/8-282j-introduction-to-astronomy-spring-2006/)

3. Carnegie Mellon University, Open Learning Initiative. "Statistical Reasoning, Unit 1: The Big Picture." This resource defines an observational study as one in which researchers "observe individuals and measure variables of interest but do not attempt to influence the responses." It contrasts this with an experiment where a treatment is deliberately imposed. (Available at: https://oli.cmu.edu/jcourse/workbook/activity/page?context=df3e40420a0001dc345c41a52a1b1c53, Module 1: Types of Statistical Studies)

Scroll to Top