L4M5 practice question 24 of 35

Procurement gets involved in negotiating purchase requisitions only when there is a value analysis to ensure that only value-adding aspects are included. Is this statement true?

Full set: 275 questions
Answer options
A: No, purchasing can negotiate other details of the purchase requisition even where value analysis is absent Correct answer
B: No, value analysis is a very technical process that requires the expertise of engineering and financial analysts
C: Yes, the role of purchasing is to add value to the purchase, and therefore every purchase requisition must go through a team value analysis
D: Yes, value analysis is the single most important responsibility of procurement in the processing of repeat requisitions
Correct Answer:
A. No, purchasing can negotiate other details of the purchase requisition even where value analysis is absent
Explanation

The statement is false. Procurement's involvement in negotiating purchase requisitions is not contingent solely upon value analysis. While value analysis is a crucial tool for cost reduction and function improvement, procurement professionals routinely negotiate many other critical commercial aspects of a requisition. These include price, delivery schedules, payment terms, quality standards, and transportation logistics. Limiting their negotiation role to instances involving value analysis would severely restrict their ability to add value across the entire procurement cycle. Procurement's objective is to secure the best overall value, which encompasses more than just the functional aspects examined in value analysis.

Why Incorrect

B. While value analysis can be technical, this fact does not define the entire scope of procurement's negotiation responsibilities for a purchase requisition.
C. This is an overstatement. It is neither practical nor necessary for every single purchase requisition to undergo a formal team value analysis.
D. This is incorrect. While important, value analysis is not the 'single most important' responsibility, and other factors like price and delivery are equally critical.

References

Lysons, K., & Farrington, B. (2020). Procurement and Supply Chain Management (10th ed.). Pearson. (Chapter 6, 'Sourcing', discusses the breadth of procurement's role in evaluating requisitions beyond just value analysis, covering commercial aspects like price, delivery, and terms).

CIPS. (2018). L4M5 Commercial Negotiation Study Guide. Profex Publishing. (Unit 2.1, 'The Commercial Negotiation Process', outlines the various elements subject to negotiation, which are not limited to value analysis outcomes).

Scroll to Top