S90-04 practice question 9 of 35

Two service delivery projects are being carried out concurrently. Each project has its own project team. Even though both projects are delivering…

Full set: 100 questions
Two service delivery projects are being carried out concurrently. Each project has its own project team. Even though both projects are delivering services for the same service inventory, each project team is given complete independence as to how services are designed and developed and what design standards are to be used. Which of the following statements describes a likely consequence of this approach?
Answer options
A: The service inventory will be comprised of services that comply to different design standards and these services will therefore not be compatible or interoperable.
B: Services with redundant and overlapping logic may be delivered because no effort was made to coordinate the delivery of the services between the two projects.
C: One project team may decide to follow a top-down delivery approach, whereas the other project team may follow a bottom-up delivery approach.
D: All of the above. Correct answer
Correct Answer:
D. All of the above.
Explanation

The scenario describes a complete lack of SOA governance, where project teams operate in silos despite contributing to a common service inventory. This absence of centralized oversight, standards, and coordination inevitably leads to all the listed consequences. Teams will naturally adopt different design standards, leading to incompatible services (A). Without a shared view of the service portfolio, redundant logic will be developed (B). Furthermore, complete independence allows teams to choose different, and potentially conflicting, delivery methodologies (C). Therefore, all statements describe likely outcomes of this ungoverned approach.

Why Incorrect

A: This is a correct statement but incomplete. It only addresses the issue of incompatible standards, ignoring the equally likely problems of redundancy and divergent methodologies. B: This is a correct statement but incomplete. It focuses only on redundant logic and overlooks the critical issues of technical incompatibility and inconsistent delivery approaches. C: This is a correct statement but incomplete. While different delivery approaches are a probable result, this option omits the significant consequences of functional redundancy and non-interoperability.

References

1. Erl, T. (2008). SOA: Principles of Service Design. Prentice Hall.

Page 498, Section 17.2 (What is SOA Governance?): This section explains that SOA governance introduces "control... that would otherwise not exist," preventing the "uncontrolled and unmonitored" proliferation of services. The lack of this control directly leads to the issues described in options A, B, and C.

Page 503, Section 17.3 (Effects of SOA Governance): It is stated that governance helps "avoid the creation of redundant or overlapping services" (addressing option B) and establishes "standardization of service design" (addressing option A).

Page 478, Section 16.2 (Top-down strategy) & Page 482, Section 16.3 (Bottom-up strategy): These sections describe distinct delivery strategies. Without a governing body to align projects, teams are free to choose different approaches independently (addressing option C).

2. Josuttis, N. (2007). SOA in Practice: The Art of Distributed System Design. O'Reilly Media.

Chapter 3, Page 37 (The Need for SOA Governance): The text explicitly warns, "Without any governance, you will end up with a bunch of services that don't fit together, are redundant, and are not what the business needs." This statement directly supports that options A, B, and C are all likely consequences.

Scroll to Top