S90-04 practice question 16 of 35

Which of the following statements is false?

Full set: 100 questions
Answer options
A: With the bottom-up approach, services are built on an "as need" basis and are modeled to encapsulate application logic to best serve the immediate requirements of the solution.
B: The bottom-up approach is often motivated by integration needs that may require establishing point-to-point integration channels between legacy systems.
C: The bottom-up approach is focused primarily on maximizing service reuse. Therefore, special attention is paid to the documentation of service profile information that is used to create complete service catalog entries. Correct answer
D: The bottom-up approach can result in the creation of hybrid services that contain a mix of logic from different sources.
Correct Answer:
C. The bottom-up approach is focused primarily on maximizing service reuse. Therefore, special attention is paid to the documentation of service profile information that is used to create complete service catalog entries.
Explanation

The bottom-up approach to service delivery is tactical and project-driven. Its primary focus is on fulfilling immediate business requirements by rapidly creating services, often by exposing existing application logic. This approach prioritizes speed of delivery for a specific solution over long-term, enterprise-wide strategic goals. Conversely, maximizing service reuse and investing in comprehensive documentation for a service catalog are hallmarks of the strategic, top-down approach, which aims to build an agile and reusable service inventory. Therefore, the statement that the bottom-up approach is focused primarily on maximizing reuse is false.

Why Incorrect

A. This statement is true. The bottom-up approach is reactive and builds services on an "as needed" basis to solve the immediate problems of a specific project or solution.
B. This statement is true. A common driver for the bottom-up approach is the tactical need to integrate existing, often disparate, legacy systems to solve a pressing business problem.
D. This statement is true. To meet a specific project's requirements, a bottom-up approach may necessitate creating a service that wraps and combines logic from multiple different legacy sources, resulting in a hybrid service.

References

1. Erl, T. (2008). SOA: Principles of Service Design. Prentice Hall.

Page 128, Section "The bottom-up approach": "The emphasis of a bottom-up design is on fulfilling immediate requirements... Services are therefore created on an 'as needed' basis..." This supports the validity of statement A.

Page 127, Section "The top-down approach": "The primary goal of this process is to create a service inventory blueprint that represents an ideal collection of services that are agile, reusable, and non-redundant." This directly contrasts with the bottom-up approach, demonstrating that statement C is false as it misattributes the primary goal of the top-down approach to the bottom-up approach.

Page 128, Figure 4.13: This figure illustrates how the bottom-up approach starts from existing technology and project requirements, which aligns with the integration motivation described in statement B and the potential for creating hybrid services mentioned in statement D.

Scroll to Top