S90-04 practice question 29 of 35

Which of the following statements is true?

Full set: 100 questions
Answer options
A: The meet-in-the-middle delivery approach allows an on-going top-down analysis to occur while services are designed and delivered. The only requirement is that delivered services eventually be updated to be kept in alignment with the results of the top-down analysis. Correct answer
B: The meet-in-the-middle delivery approach is essentially based on the bottom-up approach in that it allows services to be delivered without up-front analysis. The only difference is that the meet-in- the-middle approach advocates the use of object-orientation principles instead of service-orientation principles.
C: The meet-in-the-middle delivery approach is essentially based on the top-down approach in that it allows services to be delivered after the completion of the top-down analysis. The only difference is that the meet-in-the-middle approach advocates the use of people that act as mediators who ensure that business analysts and technology architects can collaborate harmoniously.
D: None of these statements are true.
Correct Answer:
A. The meet-in-the-middle delivery approach allows an on-going top-down analysis to occur while services are designed and delivered. The only requirement is that delivered services eventually be updated to be kept in alignment with the results of the top-down analysis.
Explanation

The meet-in-the-middle approach is a hybrid service delivery strategy that balances long-term strategic goals with short-term tactical needs. It allows an organization to proceed with a formal, top-down service-oriented analysis to define a target service inventory while simultaneously delivering services for immediate project requirements. This parallel process provides agility. However, a core tenet of this approach is that the services delivered tactically are designed with the explicit understanding that they will be refactored and evolved to conform to the standards and models produced by the on-going top-down analysis, ensuring eventual strategic alignment.

Why Incorrect

B. This approach is a hybrid of top-down and bottom-up strategies and is fundamentally based on service-orientation principles, not object-orientation.
C. This approach is characterized by the concurrent execution of analysis and delivery, not the sequential completion of analysis before delivery begins.
D. Statement A provides an accurate description of the meet-in-the-middle delivery approach, rendering this option incorrect.

References

1. Erl, T. (2008). SOA: Principles of Service Design. Prentice Hall. In Chapter 16, "Service-Oriented Design (Part II: Service Design)," the section on "A Hybrid (Meet-in-the-Middle) Approach" explains: "This approach essentially allows a top-down analysis to be performed, while services are still delivered on a project-by-project basis... The key to this approach is that the services delivered as part of the bottom-up projects are built in alignment with the service models being defined as part of the top-down analysis." (p. 499).

2. Erl, T. (2005). Service-Oriented Architecture: Concepts, Technology, and Design. Prentice Hall. Chapter 13, "Common Pitfalls in Adopting SOA," implicitly supports the need for a balanced approach, stating that a pure bottom-up approach can lead to tactical, non-standardized services, while a pure top-down can be too slow. The meet-in-the-middle strategy is presented as the pragmatic compromise that addresses these pitfalls. (pp. 450-452).

Scroll to Top