S90-04 practice question 26 of 35

Which of the following statements makes sense?

Full set: 100 questions
Answer options
A: The bottom-up approach is tactical (short-term) and therefore advocates that up-front analysis effort be carried out before the service inventory blueprint is finalized.
B: The top-down approach is tactical (short-term) and therefore advocates that up-front analysis effort be carried out before the service inventory blueprint is finalized.
C: The bottom-up approach is strategic (long-term) and therefore advocates that up-front analysis effort be carried out before the service inventory blueprint is finalized.
D: The top-down approach is strategic (long-term) and therefore advocates that up-front analysis effort be carried out before the service inventory blueprint is finalized. Correct answer
Correct Answer:
D. The top-down approach is strategic (long-term) and therefore advocates that up-front analysis effort be carried out before the service inventory blueprint is finalized.
Explanation

The top-down approach to service-oriented analysis is inherently strategic and long-term. It begins by analyzing the organization's business models and strategic goals to derive a comprehensive, enterprise-wide service inventory. This process necessitates a significant up-front analysis effort to model business processes, identify potential service candidates, and establish a standardized service inventory blueprint. This blueprint acts as a master plan, ensuring that the resulting services are aligned with the long-term vision of the business, promoting reusability, and preventing redundant, tactical solutions.

Why Incorrect

A. The bottom-up approach is tactical and focuses on short-term project needs by exposing existing application logic, thereby minimizing, not advocating for, extensive up-front analysis.
B. The top-down approach is strategic and long-term, not tactical. Its primary goal is to align IT with the business's future state, which is a strategic endeavor.
C. The bottom-up approach is tactical and short-term, not strategic. It is a reactive approach driven by existing technology, not long-term business goals.

References

1. Erl, T. (2008). SOA Principles of Service Design. Prentice Hall.

Page 102, Chapter 4, Section "Top-down strategy": "The top-down approach is considered the most pure and ideal. It advocates the creation of a service inventory that is based on a top-to-bottom analysis of the business. ... This is a long-term strategy that places a great deal of importance on up-front analysis."

Page 103, Chapter 4, Section "Bottom-up strategy": "The bottom-up approach is essentially the opposite. Instead of starting with the business, it looks at the existing technology and the legacy applications that are already in place. ... This is a tactical approach that is generally more short-term in nature."

2. Arcitura Education Inc. (2023). S90.02 SOA Technology Concepts Course Outline. Arcitura.

Module 3: Service-Oriented Analysis and Design: This module explicitly covers "the top-down 'service-oriented' analysis process" and "the bottom-up 'service-oriented' design process." The curriculum materials detail how the top-down process is driven by business requirements and results in a service inventory blueprint, contrasting it with the technology-driven, tactical nature of the bottom-up approach.

Scroll to Top