S90-18 practice question 2 of 15

The application of the __________ pattern can eliminate the need for__________. However, the application of this pattern can also introduce increased dependency on __________ that can result in a single point of failure for multiple services.

Full set: 98 questions
Answer options
A: Data Origin Authentication, distributed tokens, a single token
B: Direct Authentication, multiple identity stores, a central identity store
C: Brokered Authentication, distributed tokens, a central token
D: None of the above Correct answer
Correct Answer:
D. None of the above
Explanation

The question describes the trade-offs of the Brokered Authentication design pattern. This pattern centralizes authentication by using a broker (e.g., an identity provider), which eliminates the need for each service to manage its own authentication logic and user identity stores. However, this centralization introduces a significant dependency on the authentication broker. If this central broker fails, it becomes a single point of failure, preventing access to all services that rely on it. None of the provided options (A, B, C) accurately describe this scenario. Option C correctly identifies the pattern as "Brokered Authentication" but incorrectly states the resulting dependency is on "a central token." The dependency and single point of failure is the central authentication broker or service itself, not the token artifact it issues.

Why Incorrect

A. Data Origin Authentication, distributed tokens, a single token: The Data Origin Authentication pattern is used to verify message integrity and origin, not to centralize user authentication, making the entire premise incorrect.
B. Direct Authentication, multiple identity stores, a central identity store: The Direct Authentication pattern is the opposite of what is described; it often leads to the proliferation of multiple, distributed identity stores, rather than eliminating them.
C. Brokered Authentication, distributed tokens, a central token: While the pattern name is correct, the dependency is on the central broker/service, not "a central token." This technical inaccuracy makes the option invalid.

References

1. Erl, T. (2009). SOA Design Patterns. Prentice Hall. In the description of the Brokered Authentication pattern (Pattern 7.5), the "Consequences" section explicitly states: "The authentication broker can become a performance bottleneck and a single point of failure" and "There is an increased dependency on the authentication broker." (pp. 483-484). This confirms the dependency is on the broker, not a token.

2. National Institute of Standards and Technology (NIST). (2017). Special Publication 800-63-3: Digital Identity Guidelines. In Section 6, "Federation and Assertions," the architecture described relies on a central Identity Provider (IdP), which is an implementation of a broker. The availability of the entire federated system is dependent on the availability of the IdP. (Section 6.1.1, "Parties in a Federated Identity System"). DOI: https://doi.org/10.6028/NIST.SP.800-63-3

3. Schumacher, M., Fernandez-Buglioni, E., Hybertson, D., Buschmann, F., & Sommerlad, P. (2006). Security Patterns: Integrating Security and Systems Engineering. John Wiley & Sons. The "Authenticator" pattern describes a central component for authentication, noting the trade-off: "The Authenticator is a single point of failure. If it is compromised, the security of the whole system is at risk." (Chapter 4, p. 129).

Scroll to Top