S90-18 practice question 5 of 15

The messages exchanged between two services are kept confidential by using symmetric encryption. The security specialist is quite strict about making…

Full set: 98 questions
The messages exchanged between two services are kept confidential by using symmetric encryption. The security specialist is quite strict about making sure that no attacker is able to intercept and decipher messages sent between these two services. As a result, periodic audits are conducted in order to ensure that shared keys are always kept confidential. A single shared key has been in use for quite some time now. The security specialist was confident that all keys were well guarded, but just recently their security was compromised. How is this possible given that the shared key was never lost?
Answer options
A: Symmetric encryption is not intended for long-term use. It needs to be replaced with asymmetric encryption after some time.
B: The attackers somehow figured out which encryption algorithm was used. As a result, they were able to decipher the messages.
C: Because the same shared key was used for a long time, attackers were able to obtain the key by comparing messages sent between the two services. Correct answer
D: The shared key was decoded by the attackers using algorithms from related private keys used during prior message exchanges.
Correct Answer:
C. Because the same shared key was used for a long time, attackers were able to obtain the key by comparing messages sent between the two services.
Explanation

The prolonged use of a single, static symmetric key significantly increases the risk of compromise through cryptanalysis. When the same key is used to encrypt a large volume of messages over time, an attacker can collect a substantial amount of corresponding ciphertext. This large dataset can be subjected to various analytical techniques (such as frequency analysis or known-plaintext attacks) to identify statistical patterns. These patterns can eventually be exploited to deduce the secret key, thereby compromising the confidentiality of all messages encrypted with it, without the key ever being directly stolen. This is a fundamental reason for implementing key rotation policies.

Why Incorrect

A. Symmetric encryption is suitable for long-term use; however, the keys must be changed periodically. Asymmetric encryption is generally used for key exchange or digital signatures, not as a direct replacement for bulk data encryption due to its computational overhead.
B. Modern cryptographic security relies on the secrecy of the key, not the algorithm (Kerckhoffs's Principle). Standard, well-known algorithms like AES are used publicly, and knowing the algorithm does not enable an attacker to decipher messages without the key.
D. This statement incorrectly conflates symmetric and asymmetric cryptography. Symmetric encryption uses a single shared key. Private keys are a component of asymmetric (public-key) cryptography and are not used in the described scenario.

References

1. National Institute of Standards and Technology (NIST) Special Publication 800-57 Part 1, Revision 5, "Recommendation for Key Management":

Section 5.3, Cryptoperiods: This section explains that a cryptoperiod is the time span during which a specific key is authorized for use. It states, "The length of a cryptoperiod is determined by a risk analysis that is based on the security life of the key, the security of the keying material, and the amount of information protected by a key... Using a single key for a long period of time or to protect a large amount of information increases the risk of key compromise." This directly supports the reasoning that long-term key use is a vulnerability.

2. Stallings, W. (2017). Cryptography and Network Security: Principles and Practice (7th ed.). Pearson.

Chapter 2, "Classical Encryption Techniques," Section 2.3, Cryptanalysis: This chapter details how attackers use statistical properties of the language and ciphertext to break ciphers. It explains that the more ciphertext an attacker has available, the more effective these attacks become. This principle underpins the correct answer (C), where long-term use of a key provides attackers with ample material for analysis.

3. Arcitura Education Inc. (2017). S90.09: SOA Security Lab Study Kit.

The official course materials for the S90.09 exam emphasize the importance of key management practices. The curriculum covers the vulnerabilities associated with static keys and the necessity of key rotation to mitigate risks like cryptanalysis, which becomes more feasible as more data is encrypted with the same key. This aligns with the scenario where a long-used key is compromised.

Scroll to Top