SECURE-SOFTWARE-DESIGN practice question 9 of 25

The product security incident response team (PSIRT) has decided to make a formal public disclosure, including base and temporal common vulnerability scoring system (CVSS) scores and a common vulnerabilities and exposures (CVE) ID report, of an externally discovered vulnerability. What is the most likely reason for making a public disclosure?

Full set: 118 questions

Domain Software Security Throughout the Lifecycle

Answer options
A: The potential for increased public awareness of a vulnerability is probable, which could lead to higher risk for customers.
B: The vulnerability reporter has threatened to make the finding public after being notified that their case was not credible.
C: The response team has determined that the vulnerability is credible. Correct answer
D: Notification of a vulnerability from an external party has occurred.
Correct Answer:
C. The response team has determined that the vulnerability is credible.
Explanation

A Product Security Incident Response Team (PSIRT) follows a structured process for handling vulnerability reports. A formal public disclosure, which includes assigning a CVE ID and CVSS scores, is a critical step in the Coordinated Vulnerability Disclosure (CVD) lifecycle. This action is only taken after the PSIRT has completed its internal investigation and triage process, which involves validating the report, reproducing the issue, and confirming its security impact. Therefore, the determination that the vulnerability is credible and affects the product is the fundamental prerequisite and primary reason for proceeding with a formal public disclosure to inform customers and the security community.

Why Incorrect

A. Increased public awareness leading to higher risk is a potential negative outcome that disclosure aims to mitigate with patches, not the reason for the disclosure itself.
B. A PSIRT would not issue a formal CVE and CVSS score for a vulnerability it has determined is not credible; such a report would be closed or rejected.
D. Notification from an external party only initiates the investigation process; it does not automatically trigger a public disclosure without prior validation and confirmation of credibility.

References

1. FIRST.org, "PSIRT Services Framework," Version 1.1, Section 3.3, Vulnerability Handling (p. 13). The framework outlines the typical PSIRT workflow as Triage -> Investigation -> Remediation -> Disclosure. This sequential process shows that disclosure occurs only after the investigation phase, where the credibility and impact of a potential vulnerability are determined.

2. Carnegie Mellon University, Software Engineering Institute (SEI), "The CERT Guide to Coordinated Vulnerability Disclosure," (2017), Section 4.2, "Analysis" (p. 21). This guide details the vulnerability analysis phase, stating, "The goal of the analysis phase is to understand a vulnerability report well enough to determine whether it describes a true vulnerability in your product or service." This confirmation is a necessary step before any disclosure activities are planned.

3. ISO/IEC 29147:2018, "Information technology — Security techniques — Vulnerability disclosure," Section 6.3, "Triage." This international standard specifies that after receiving a report, the vendor must perform a triage to "determine the report's accuracy and credibility." A decision to proceed is based on this initial validation, which precedes public disclosure.

Scroll to Top