8020 practice question 2 of 15

What are the roles of business versus risk management in developing and implementing risk assessments?

Full set: 60 questions

Domain Risk Identification and Assessment

Answer options
A: Risk management, in its role as second line of defense, performs the risk assessment process from beginning to end. There is no business line involvement.
B: The business owns the risk assessment process, while risk management develops the framework, helps facilitate the process, and provides supervision and oversight. Correct answer
C: Business owns the risk assessment process so risk management does not play a role in the process.
D: Business management's role in the risk assessment process should be confined to oversight.
Correct Answer:
B. The business owns the risk assessment process, while risk management develops the framework, helps facilitate the process, and provides supervision and oversight.
Explanation

This question addresses the fundamental roles within the "Three Lines of Defense" risk governance model. The business line, as the First Line of Defense (1LOD), owns the risks it generates. Therefore, it is responsible for identifying, assessing, and managing those risks through processes like risk assessments. The risk management function, as the Second Line of Defense (2LOD), establishes the enterprise-wide risk management framework, methodologies, and policies. It provides expertise, facilitates the risk assessment process, and offers independent oversight and challenge to the first line's activities to ensure consistency and effectiveness.

Why Incorrect

A. This is incorrect because the second line (risk management) provides oversight and framework, but the first line (business) performs the day-to-day risk management, including the assessment itself.
C. This is incorrect. While the business owns the process, the risk management function plays a critical oversight, framework development, and challenge role. It is a partnership, not an abdication of responsibility.
D. This is incorrect because oversight is the primary role of the second line (risk management), not the first line. The business's role is active ownership and management of its risks.

References

1. Basel Committee on Banking Supervision (BCBS). (2021). Principles for the sound management of operational risk (revised). Bank for International Settlements.

Principle 3

Paragraph 21(a): "The first line of defence is the business line that creates the risks... Business line management is responsible for identifying

assessing

controlling and mitigating risks inherent in their products

activities

processes and systems."

Principle 3

Paragraph 21(b): "The second line of defence is the independent operational risk management function... It is responsible for developing and implementing the bank-wide operational risk management framework... challenging the business lines’ risk management activities..."

2. The Institute of Internal Auditors (IIA). (2020). The IIA’s Three Lines Model.

First Line Roles (Management): "First line roles are most directly aligned with the delivery of products and/or services to clients of the organization

and include the support functions... They also own and manage risks."

Second Line Roles: "Second line roles provide assistance with managing risk... Typical second line roles include... risk management... They provide expertise

support

monitoring

and challenge on risk-related matters."

3. Fraser

J. R. S.

& Simkins

B. J. (Eds.). (2010). Enterprise Risk Management: Today's Leading Research and Best Practices for Tomorrow's Executives. John Wiley & Sons.

In Chapter 10

"A Practical and Proven Approach to ERM

" the authors describe the roles

stating that business unit managers are responsible for "identifying and assessing risks" while the corporate risk management group is responsible for "developing the common risk management framework (language

processes

and tools)." This aligns directly with the correct answer.

Scroll to Top