8020 practice question 7 of 15
How should Near Misses and Opportunity Costs be treated within Operational Risk?
Full set: 60 questionsNear misses and opportunity costs are treated differently but share a common outcome regarding capital calculation. Near misses are operational risk events that do not result in a financial loss but highlight control weaknesses. They are extremely valuable for proactive risk management and should be reported, recorded, and analyzed to prevent future actual losses. Opportunity costs, which are revenues foregone due to choosing one alternative over another, are generally considered a business or strategic risk, not an operational risk loss under regulatory frameworks like Basel. Therefore, while both may be recorded for internal management purposes, neither is used in the quantitative models for calculating regulatory operational risk capital, which are based on actual, realized financial losses.
A. Ignored. Ignoring near misses means losing critical, low-cost information about control failures that could lead to significant future losses.
B. Recorded and Analyzed. Used in calculation of Operational Risk Capital. This is incorrect because near misses have a financial loss of zero and opportunity costs are not direct losses; they cannot be used in loss distribution models for capital.
D. Reported, Recorded and Analyzed, Used in calculation of Operational Risk Capital. This is incorrect for the same reason as B. Standard practice and regulatory guidance exclude zero-loss events and opportunity costs from operational risk capital calculations. ---
1. Basel Committee on Banking Supervision (BCBS). (June 2006). International Convergence of Capital Measurement and Capital Standards: A Revised Framework - Comprehensive Version. Bank for International Settlements.
Reference: Paragraph 644 defines operational risk as "the risk of loss resulting from inadequate or failed internal processes
people and systems or from external events." This definition focuses on actual losses. Guidance notes accompanying the framework typically clarify that this excludes opportunity costs.
Reference: Annex 9
"Minimum quantitative standards for AMA
" details the requirements for loss data used in capital models. The framework is built on modeling the frequency and severity of actual loss events
making the inclusion of zero-loss near misses or non-loss opportunity costs inappropriate for the capital calculation itself.
2. Cruz
M. G.
Peters
G. W.
& Shevchenko
P. V. (2015). Fundamental Aspects of Operational Risk and Insurance Analytics: A Handbook of Operational Risk. John Wiley & Sons.
Reference: Chapter 2
Section 2.2.1
"Definition of Operational Risk." The text clarifies the scope of operational risk losses
noting that regulatory definitions (like Basel's) exclude opportunity costs. It states
"The Basel II definition of operational risk is a definition of operational loss... It excludes opportunity costs."
Reference: Chapter 10
"Loss Data Collection." This chapter discusses the importance of collecting data on near misses for qualitative analysis and understanding risk profiles
but distinguishes this from the collection of actual loss data used for capital modeling.
3. Muermann
A.
& Oktem
U. (2002). The near-miss management of operational risk. The Journal of Risk Finance
3(2)
25-36.
Reference: Abstract & Section 2. The paper argues that "near-miss information is a valuable but underutilized source of information for the management of operational risk." It proposes using near-miss data to better estimate the frequency of loss events but confirms that near misses themselves are not loss events to be included in a severity distribution for capital calculation. DOI: https://doi.org/10.1108/eb022921
Keep practicing
Take the free 8020 practice test
Ten exam-style questions with answers and explanations, plus the exam facts and study guides.
More questions
Other 8020 practice questions
- Question 1How can a chief risk officer encourage the governing body and executive management team t…
- Question 2What are the roles of business versus risk management in developing and implementing risk…
- Question 3For the Northern Rock case study, what was the low-probability-high-impact event that was…
- Question 4For the FTX case study, what was the "backdoor" used for?
- Question 5In relation to the template for writing policy documents, which one of the following pair…
- Question 6What are some of the properties of Bottom-Up KRIs?
