8020 practice question 8 of 15

Which of the following principles best applies to a compliance function?

Full set: 60 questions
Answer options
A: The compliance function should report to the business (even when following a three lines of defense model).
B: The compliance function should be independent of the business (following a three lines of defense model). Correct answer
C: The compliance function should be outsourced if there is a risk function.
D: The risk function should be outsourced if there is a compliance function.
Correct Answer:
B. The compliance function should be independent of the business (following a three lines of defense model).
Explanation

The "three lines of defense" model is a fundamental framework for risk management and governance. In this model, the compliance function is a key component of the second line. The first line consists of the business units that own and manage risks. The second line's primary role is to provide oversight, expertise, and challenge to the first line. For this oversight to be effective and credible, the second line, including compliance, must be independent of the business units it oversees. This independence prevents conflicts of interest and ensures objective monitoring and reporting on compliance matters.

Why Incorrect

A. Reporting to the business creates a direct conflict of interest, undermining the compliance function's ability to provide objective oversight and challenge, which is its core purpose in the three lines model.
C. The risk and compliance functions are distinct but complementary second-line functions. The existence of a risk function does not negate the need for an internal compliance function or justify its outsourcing.
D. The risk function is a critical internal capability. Outsourcing it because a compliance function exists is illogical, as they address different, albeit related, aspects of organizational risk and governance. ---

References

1. The Institute of Internal Auditors (IIA). (2020). The IIA’s Three Lines Model.

Reference: Page 4

"Principles of the Three Lines Model

" Principle 3: "Roles in the second line... are separate from those in the first line and from management’s responsibility to achieve objectives." This document explicitly states that second-line functions (like compliance) must be separate from first-line management to maintain independence and objectivity.

2. Basel Committee on Banking Supervision (BCBS). (2015). Corporate governance principles for banks. Bank for International Settlements.

Reference: Page 24

Principle 8

Paragraph 81: "The bank’s compliance function should be independent... The compliance function should have a formal status within the bank... and have a reporting line to the head of compliance

who should have a reporting line to the board or a board committee and the CEO." This principle directly mandates the independence of the compliance function.

3. Moeller

R. R. (2014). Executive's Guide to COSO Internal Controls: Understanding and Implementing the New Framework. John Wiley & Sons.

Reference: Chapter 11

"The Three Lines of Defense Model of Enterprise Risk Management." This chapter explains that the second line of defense functions

including compliance

"are separate from the first line of defense and report up through their own separate lines of management." This separation is crucial for effective oversight.

Scroll to Top