API-580 practice question 8 of 25

Depending on the methodology employed in qualitative analysis, the categories may be described with words such as

Full set: 140 questions
Answer options
A: High, medium or low or may have numerical descriptors. Correct answer
B: High, medium or low only
C: Numerical descriptors only
Correct Answer:
A. High, medium or low or may have numerical descriptors.
Explanation

Qualitative risk analysis uses expert judgment to categorize the probability and consequence of failure into descriptive levels. The most common descriptors are words like "High," "Medium," and "Low." However, to facilitate ranking and representation in a risk matrix, these descriptive categories are often assigned corresponding numerical values (e.g., 1 to 5). This allows for a more structured, albeit still qualitative, assessment. Therefore, the methodology can employ descriptive words, numerical descriptors, or a combination of both to define the risk categories. Options B and C are incorrect because they are overly restrictive.

Why Incorrect

B. High, medium or low only: This is incorrect because numerical descriptors are also commonly used in qualitative methodologies to rank the categories.
C. Numerical descriptors only: This is incorrect as the foundation of qualitative analysis is descriptive language; numbers are used to represent these descriptions.

References

1. American Petroleum Institute. (2016). API Standard 580, Risk-Based Inspection (3rd ed.). Section 9.2, "Qualitative Risk Analysis." The text explicitly states, "The categories may be described with words such as high, medium, or low, or may have numerical descriptors (e.g. 1, 2, 3, 4, 5)."

Scroll to Top