CFM practice question 14 of 35

What is the relationship between position power and personal influence?

Full set: 251 questions
Answer options
A: Position power alone is sufficient for effective leadership
B: Position power can create personal influence
C: Personal influence cannot be attained without first having a position of power
D: Personal influence and position power come from different sources Correct answer
Correct Answer:
D. Personal influence and position power come from different sources
Explanation

Position power and personal influence are distinct concepts that originate from different sources. Position power is a form of formal authority granted by an organization based on an individual's title or role in the hierarchy (e.g., manager, director). It includes legitimate, reward, and coercive power. In contrast, personal influence is an informal power that an individual earns based on their own characteristics, such as their expertise, skills, integrity, and interpersonal relationships. This includes expert and referent power. While an effective leader may possess both, one is not a prerequisite for the other, and they are not derived from the same source.

Why Incorrect

A. Position power alone is sufficient for effective leadership: Effective leadership relies on commitment and engagement, which are better cultivated through personal influence rather than solely through the compliance compelled by position power.
B. Position power can create personal influence: A position provides a platform, but it does not automatically confer personal influence. Personal influence must be earned through actions, expertise, and building trust.
C. Personal influence cannot be attained without first having a position of power: Individuals can be highly influential informal leaders within an organization due to their expertise or relationships, without holding any formal position of authority.

References

1. French, J. R. P., & Raven, B. (1959). The bases of social power. In D. Cartwright (Ed.), Studies in social power (pp. 150-167). University of Michigan, Institute for Social Research. This foundational study categorizes power into five bases, clearly distinguishing between those derived from organizational position (legitimate, reward, coercive) and those derived from personal attributes (expert, referent).

2. Yukl, G., & Gardner, W. L. (2020). Leadership in organizations (9th ed.). Pearson. Chapter 7, "Power and Influence," explicitly differentiates between position power, which "is derived from the opportunities inherent in a person's position in the organization," and personal power, which "is derived from the attributes of the person and their relationship with others."

3. Northouse, P. G. (2018). Leadership: Theory and practice (8th ed.). Sage publications. In Chapter 1, "Introduction," Northouse discusses the difference between assigned leadership (based on a formal position) and emergent leadership (based on how others perceive an individual), reinforcing that power and influence can come from sources other than a formal title. This text is standard courseware in university leadership programs.

Scroll to Top