CFM practice question 34 of 35

What sequential steps should you follow when trying to settle a contract dispute with a contractor?

Full set: 251 questions
Answer options
A: Mediation, arbitration, litigation, and negotiation
B: Mediation, negotiations, arbitration, and litigation
C: Negotiations, mediation, arbitration, and litigation Correct answer
D: Negotiations, arbitration, mediation, and litigation
Correct Answer:
C. Negotiations, mediation, arbitration, and litigation
Explanation

The standard process for resolving contract disputes follows a logical sequence of escalation, moving from the least formal and least expensive method to the most formal and costly. The process begins with direct negotiation between the parties to find a mutual agreement. If negotiations fail, the next step is mediation, where a neutral third party facilitates discussion to help the parties reach a voluntary settlement. If mediation is unsuccessful, the dispute proceeds to arbitration, a more formal process where a neutral arbitrator hears the case and makes a decision that is typically binding. The final resort, when all other methods have failed, is litigation, which involves resolving the dispute in a court of law.

Why Incorrect

A. This sequence is incorrect because it starts with mediation, skipping the crucial and most common first step of direct negotiation between the parties.
B. This sequence is also incorrect as it begins with mediation, failing to recognize that direct negotiation is the primary and initial method for dispute resolution.
D. This sequence incorrectly places arbitration before mediation. Mediation is a less adversarial, non-binding process designed to facilitate agreement and is almost always attempted before the more formal and often binding process of arbitration.

References

1. IFMA, The Facility Management Body of Knowledge (BOK), Sourcing and Procurement Competency. The BOK outlines contract management best practices, which include a tiered approach to dispute resolution. The standard clause progression is negotiation, followed by mediation, then arbitration, and finally litigation as the last resort. This is detailed in the sections covering contract administration and supplier relationship management.

2. Roper, K. O., & Payant, R. P. (2014). The Facility Management Handbook (4th ed.). AMACOM. In Chapter 15, "Sourcing," the text discusses contract terms and conditions, emphasizing the inclusion of dispute resolution clauses that follow the negotiation-mediation-arbitration hierarchy to avoid costly litigation. (See section on Contractual Agreements).

3. Cornell University, Scheinman Institute on Conflict Resolution. Course materials for "Labor Relations: ILRLR 2050". The curriculum consistently presents the Alternative Dispute Resolution (ADR) continuum as starting with direct negotiation, moving to third-party facilitation (mediation), and then to third-party adjudication (arbitration), with litigation being the final step outside of the typical ADR process.

4. Matteson, K., & Zofnass, P. J. (2010). Alternative Dispute Resolution in the Construction Industry. Leadership and Management in Engineering, 10(4), 165–169. This peer-reviewed article describes the "dispute resolution ladder" in the related construction industry, which follows the identical sequence of negotiation, mediation, arbitration, and litigation. (p. 166). https://doi.org/10.1061/(ASCE)LM.1943-5630.0000078

Scroll to Top