CIMAPRA19-E02-1 practice question 29 of 30

A number of managers in an organisation approach change using a variety of techniques. Manager A focuses on staff training. Manager B provides large…

Full set: 210 questions
A number of managers in an organisation approach change using a variety of techniques. Manager A focuses on staff training. Manager B provides large bonuses for effective project management. Manager C restructures his team to reduce headcount. Manager D lays out the financial problems in the business and why change is unavoidable. Manager E calls his team together to openly discuss the issues. Manager F calls for ideas from his team to make the change happen. Based on Beer and Nohria's change theory, which of these managers can be described as Theory 0 managers? Select ALL that apply.
Answer options
A: Manager A Correct answer
B: Manager E Correct answer
C: Manager F Correct answer
D: Manager B
E: Manager C
F: Manager D
Correct Answer:
A. Manager A; B. Manager E; C. Manager F
Explanation

Beer and Nohria's Theory O of change focuses on developing organizational capability through a 'soft', participative approach centered on culture, learning, and employee commitment. Manager A's focus on staff training directly builds employee capability (Theory O). Manager E's use of open discussion and Manager F's call for ideas are both participative methods that aim to build consensus and commitment from the bottom up, which are hallmarks of Theory O. These approaches contrast with Theory E, which is a 'hard', top-down approach focused on economic value, structure, and systems.

Why Incorrect

D. Manager B's use of large bonuses is a financial incentive, a 'hard' lever typical of Theory E, which focuses on economic value.
E. Manager C's restructuring and headcount reduction is a structural change driven from the top down, a classic example of Theory E.
F. Manager D's focus on unavoidable financial problems represents a top-down, economically driven rationale for change, characteristic of Theory E.

References

1. Beer, M., & Nohria, N. (2000). Cracking the Code of Change. Harvard Business Review, 78(3), 133–141. This is the seminal article that introduces and defines Theory E (economic value) and Theory O (organizational capability).

2. MIT Sloan School of Management. (n.d.). 15.311 Organizational Processes. Courseware. Lecture on "Managing Change" discusses the Beer and Nohria framework, distinguishing between the 'hard' (E) and 'soft' (O) approaches.

3. Hughes, M. (2011). Do 70 per cent of all organizational change initiatives really fail? Journal of Change Management, 11(4), 451-464. https://doi.org/10.1080/14697017.2011.630506. This article reviews change models, including Beer and Nohria's, and reinforces the distinction between capability-building (O) and economic-driven (E) change.

Scroll to Top