CIMAPRA19-F03-1 practice question 32 of 35

A geared and profitable company is evaluating the best method of financing the purchase of new machinery. It is considering either buying the…

Full set: 390 questions
A geared and profitable company is evaluating the best method of financing the purchase of new machinery. It is considering either buying the machinery outright, financed by a secured bank borrowing and selling the machinery at the end of a fixed period of time or obtain the machinery under a lease for the same period of time. Which is the correct discount rate to use when discounting the incremental cash flows of the lease against those of the buy and borrow alternative?
Answer options
A: The post-tax cost of the bank borrowing Correct answer
B: The company's cost of equity
C: The company's WACC.
D: The pre-tax cost of the bank borrowing
Correct Answer:
A. The post-tax cost of the bank borrowing
Explanation

The lease versus buy decision is a financing decision, not an investment decision. The analysis compares the incremental cash flows of two different financing methods. These cash flows (e.g., lease payments, tax shields from depreciation and interest) are relatively certain and have a risk profile similar to that of debt. Therefore, the appropriate discount rate is the after-tax cost of debt, which in this case is the post-tax cost of the bank borrowing that would be used for the purchase. This rate correctly reflects the risk of the financing cash flows and accounts for the tax-deductibility of interest payments.

Why Incorrect

B. The company's cost of equity reflects the high risk of equity cash flows and is inappropriate for the low-risk, contractual cash flows of a financing decision.
C. The company's WACC is the average cost of capital for projects with average business risk. It is used for investment appraisal, not for comparing two financing alternatives.
D. The pre-tax cost of borrowing ignores the valuable tax shield on interest payments, making it an incorrect rate for comparing financing options on a post-tax basis.

References

1. Brealey, R. A., Myers, S. C., & Allen, F. (2020). Principles of Corporate Finance (13th ed.). McGraw-Hill Education. Chapter 25, Section 25-3, "A First Pass at the Lease-versus-Borrow Decision," explicitly states: "The right discount rate is the after-tax interest rate that the firm would pay on an equivalent loan."

2. Ross, S. A., Westerfield, R. W., & Jaffe, J. (2019). Corporate Finance (12th ed.). McGraw-Hill Education. Chapter 22, "Leasing," explains that the correct discount rate for lease analysis is the firm's after-tax borrowing rate.

3. Damodaran, A. (2012). Investment Valuation: Tools and Techniques for Determining the Value of Any Asset (3rd ed.). Wiley. Chapter 29, "The Value of Control," in discussions of financing decisions, confirms that the after-tax cost of debt is the appropriate rate for debt-like cash flows.

Scroll to Top