CIMAPRA19-F03-1 practice question 20 of 35

ZZZ wishes to borrow at a floating rate and has been told that it can use swaps to reduce the effective interest rate it pays. ZZZ can borrow floating at the risk-free rate + 1, and fixed at 10%. Which of the following companies would be the most appropriate for ZZZ to enter into a swap with?

Full set: 390 questions
Answer options
A: Company DDA - it can borrow at risk-free rate + 1 Vz and fixed at 10.5%
B: Company CCA - it can borrow at risk-free rate + Y% and fixed at 9% Correct answer
C: Company BBA - it can borrow floating at risk-free rate +VA and fixed at 12% Correct answer
D: Company AAB - it can borrow floating at risk-free rate + % and fixed at 9.5% Correct answer
Correct Answer:
B. Company CCA - it can borrow at risk-free rate + Y% and fixed at 9%; C. Company BBA - it can borrow floating at risk-free rate +VA and fixed at 12%; D. Company AAB - it can borrow floating at risk-free rate + % and fixed at 9.5%
Explanation

A beneficial interest rate swap is possible when a comparative advantage exists between two parties. This occurs if the difference in the fixed rates they can borrow at is not equal to the difference in their floating rates. ZZZ wants to borrow floating. A swap is viable with any counterparty where the sum of potential gains is positive.
- Company DDA: The differential is the same for both fixed (0.5%) and floating (0.5%) rates, so no comparative advantage exists.
- Companies CCA, BBA, and AAB: In all three cases, a comparative advantage exists, creating a potential gain to be shared. Therefore, all three are appropriate potential counterparties.

Why Incorrect

A. For Company DDA, the fixed rate differential (10.5% - 10% = 0.5%) equals the floating rate differential ((RFR+1.5%) - (RFR+1%) = 0.5%). There is no comparative advantage and no potential gain from a swap.

References

1. Hull, J. C. (2018). Options, Futures, and Other Derivatives (10th ed.). Pearson. Chapter 7, "Swaps," pp. 155-159, explains the conditions for a beneficial swap based on comparative advantage.

2. CIMA (2019). F3 Financial Strategy, Official Study Text. Kaplan Publishing. Chapter 10, "Interest Rate Risk Management," discusses how swaps are used to exploit comparative borrowing advantages. The total gain is calculated as the difference in the differences between interest rates.

Scroll to Top