CIPP-A practice question 15 of 15

Which of the following is NOT a way that the Singapore government can monitor its citizens?

Full set: 90 questions
Answer options
A: Through the national identity card system.
B: Through the electronic road pricing system.
C: Through a personal computer registration system. Correct answer
D: Through an online service that holds an individual’s medical records.
Correct Answer:
C. Through a personal computer registration system.
Explanation

The Singapore government does not have a general or mandatory system requiring citizens to register their personal computers. Therefore, this cannot be a method of government monitoring. In contrast, the other options represent existing systems through which the government collects data on its citizens. The National Registration Identity Card (NRIC) is a foundational identity document used across public and private sectors. The Electronic Road Pricing (ERP) system tracks vehicle movements to manage traffic congestion. The National Electronic Health Record (NEHR) system centralizes individuals' medical data, which can be used by the Ministry of Health for public health surveillance and policy-making, constituting a form of monitoring.

Why Incorrect

A. Through the national identity card system. This is incorrect. The National Registration Identity Card (NRIC) system is a primary tool for identification and data collection by the Singapore government, enabling monitoring across various services.
B. Through the electronic road pricing system. This is incorrect. The Electronic Road Pricing (ERP) system actively monitors vehicle locations and movements on tolled roads, making it a direct form of citizen surveillance.
D. Through an online service that holds an individual’s medical records. This is incorrect. Singapore's National Electronic Health Record (NEHR) system, managed by the Ministry of Health, consolidates patient data and is used for purposes including public health monitoring. ---

References

1. National Identity Card System (NRIC):

Immigration & Checkpoints Authority (ICA), Singapore. (n.d.). National Registration Identity Card (NRIC). The official government page details the mandatory nature and uses of the NRIC, which forms the basis of the national identification system. Retrieved from the official ICA Singapore website.

2. Electronic Road Pricing (ERP) System:

Land Transport Authority (LTA), Singapore. (n.d.). Electronic Road Pricing (ERP). This official source describes how the ERP system works by tracking vehicles passing through gantries, which is a form of location monitoring. Retrieved from the official LTA Singapore website.

3. National Electronic Health Record (NEHR):

Ministry of Health (MOH), Singapore. (n.d.). National Electronic Health Record (NEHR). The MOH website explains that the NEHR provides a consolidated view of a patient's health history and is used for purposes including "public health and research," which involves monitoring population health trends. Retrieved from the official MOH Singapore website.

4. Academic Review of Surveillance in Singapore:

Chesterman, S. (2014). Data Protection in Singapore: The Personal Data Protection Act 2012. National University of Singapore, Faculty of Law. In discussing the scope of data protection, the paper acknowledges extensive data collection by public sector agencies in Singapore for various purposes, implicitly covering systems like NRIC and ERP, but makes no mention of a personal computer registration system. (See discussion on public sector data governance, Section IV).

5. Absence of a PC Registration System:

There is no official documentation from the Singapore Government (e.g., Infocomm Media Development Authority - IMDA, Singapore Statutes Online) mandating a general registration system for personal computers owned by citizens. The absence of such a law or regulation confirms it is not a method of monitoring.

Scroll to Top