CLSSGB-001 practice question 27 of 30

According to a manager it takes an average weekday commute of 39 minutes with a Standard Deviation of 7 minutes for the employees to get to work when…

Full set: 200 questions
According to a manager it takes an average weekday commute of 39 minutes with a Standard Deviation of 7 minutes for the employees to get to work when they use their personal vehicles for their office commute while management set a policy of not more than 40 minutes for their daily one- way commute. A survey conducted one day on 70 employees showed an average of 34 minutes commuting time using the metro public transportation system with a Standard Deviation of 21 minutes. For the employees choosing to increase their chances to come on time using personal transportation their variation should be reduced to ___________?
Answer options
A: 1 minute
B: 6 minutes
C: 3.5 minutes Correct answer
D: Eliminate it to 0.0 minutes
Correct Answer:
C. 3.5 minutes
Explanation

The question assesses the understanding of setting practical process improvement goals. The current process for personal transportation has a standard deviation of 7 minutes. To "increase their chances to come on time," a significant reduction in this variation is required. In Lean Six Sigma projects, a common, aggressive-but-achievable goal is to reduce the variation (or defects) by 50%. Applying this principle, the target for the new standard deviation would be 50% of the current value. Current Standard Deviation = 7 minutes Target Reduction = 50% New Standard Deviation = 7 minutes 0.50 = 3.5 minutes. The data about the metro system is extraneous information intended to distract from the core question about improving the personal transportation process.

Why Incorrect

A. 1 minute: This represents an 85% reduction in variation, which may be an unrealistic initial goal, and it would still leave the specification limit only one standard deviation from the mean.
B. 6 minutes: This is only a ~14% reduction in standard deviation, which is not a significant enough improvement to meaningfully increase the chances of on-time arrival.
D. Eliminate it to 0.0 minutes: A standard deviation of zero implies a perfect process with no variation, which is a theoretical ideal but is practically unattainable in any real-world scenario.

References

1. Pyzdek, T., & Keller, P. A. (2018). The Six Sigma Handbook (5th ed.). McGraw-Hill Education. In Chapter 14, "Define Phase," when discussing the project charter and setting goals, it is noted that improvement goals should be aggressive. An example provided is to "Reduce the variation in delivery time by 50%." This establishes the 50% reduction as a standard benchmark for improvement projects.

2. George, M. L. (2002). Lean Six Sigma: Combining Six Sigma Quality with Lean Speed. McGraw-Hill. In Chapter 3, "How Lean Six Sigma Works," the text discusses setting project goals that are significant and measurable. A 50 percent improvement is frequently cited as a typical target for a single DMAIC project's primary metric, including measures of variation.

3. De Feo, J. A. (2017). Juran's Quality Handbook: The Complete Guide to Performance Excellence (7th ed.). McGraw-Hill Education. Chapter 14, "The Juran Trilogy," discusses the Quality Improvement process, which involves setting specific, measurable goals for projects. While not prescribing a single number, the methodology emphasizes breakthrough improvements, for which a 50% reduction in non-conformance or variation is a common industry interpretation and starting point for project charters.

Scroll to Top