CLSSGB-001 practice question 22 of 30

The 5 Why Analysis is only useful if the possible independent variable can be broken down into five possible causes.

Full set: 200 questions
Answer options
A: True
B: False Correct answer
Correct Answer:
B. False
Explanation

The statement is a misrepresentation of the 5 Whys analysis. The "5" in the name is not a rigid requirement for the number of possible causes of a variable. Instead, it serves as a general guideline for the number of times one should iteratively ask the question "Why?" to trace a problem's symptoms back to its fundamental root cause. The objective is to follow a chain of causality, not to brainstorm a fixed number of causes. The actual number of iterations may be more or less than five, depending on the complexity of the issue being investigated. The technique's utility lies in its structured, in-depth questioning to prevent superficial solutions.

Why Incorrect

A. True: This is incorrect. The 5 Whys technique is a root cause analysis tool based on sequential questioning, not on the prerequisite that a variable must have five distinct causes.

References

1. Serrat, O. (2017). The Five Whys Technique. In: Knowledge Solutions. Springer, Singapore. https://doi.org/10.1007/978-981-10-0983-932

Page 308, Section "The Five Whys Process": "Five is a rule of thumb... The real key is to avoid assumptions and logic traps and instead trace the chain of causality in direct increments from the effect through any layers of abstraction to a root cause that is still somehow connected to the original problem." This confirms that "five" is a guideline for the depth of inquiry, not the number of causes.

2. Massachusetts Institute of Technology (MIT). (2011). Lean Advancement Initiative - The 5 Whys Technique. ESD.60 Lean/Six Sigma Systems.

Page 1: The document states, "The '5' in 5 Whys is just a 'rule of thumb'. In some instances you may get to the root-cause in less than 5 Whys. In others you may need more than 5 Whys." This directly refutes the idea that the technique is only useful under the condition stated in the question.

3. American Society for Quality (ASQ). What is 5 Whys?. ASQ.org.

Section "When to Use 5 Whys": "The '5' is a rule of thumb; you may need to ask 'why' fewer or more times before you find the issue's root cause." This resource, from a leading quality management body, clarifies that the number is a guideline for the iterative process.

Scroll to Top