S90-18 practice question 15 of 15

Service A is a utility service that has been designed to receive and send non-confidential messages. Service A provides access to a legacy…

Full set: 98 questions
Service A is a utility service that has been designed to receive and send non-confidential messages. Service A provides access to a legacy application. Since the launch of Service A . the overall usage volumes have increased beyond expectations. Upon a review of the access logs, it is discovered that most of the requests came from unauthorized service consumers. The application of the Direct Authentication and Data Confidentiality patterns will prevent this from happening in the future.
Answer options
A: True
B: False
Correct Answer:
FALSE
Explanation

The core problem identified is that unauthorized service consumers are accessing Service A. This is an issue of authentication and authorization, not data confidentiality. The Direct Authentication pattern directly addresses this problem by requiring service consumers to present credentials that can be validated to confirm their identity. This would prevent unauthorized consumers from successfully making requests. However, the Data Confidentiality pattern is designed to protect the contents of a message from being read by unauthorized parties, typically through encryption. The scenario explicitly states that the messages are "non-confidential." Therefore, applying the Data Confidentiality pattern is irrelevant to solving the problem of unauthorized access and is an inappropriate solution for the given context. Because the proposed solution includes an unnecessary and mismatched pattern, the statement as a whole is incorrect.

Why Incorrect

The statement would be considered "True" only if both patterns were relevant to solving the stated problem. While Direct Authentication is the correct pattern to apply, the inclusion of Data Confidentiality for non-confidential data makes the proposed solution flawed from a design pattern application perspective. The goal is to apply the correct patterns for the specific problem, and Data Confidentiality does not fit this problem description.

References

1. Erl, T., et al. (2009). SOA Design Patterns. Prentice Hall.

Direct Authentication Pattern (p. 311): "How can a service authenticate the identity of a message sender? The service consumer is required to send authentication credentials together with the message, which are then authenticated by the service provider." This reference confirms that Direct Authentication is the pattern for verifying the sender's identity, which is the core of the problem.

Data Confidentiality Pattern (p. 319): "How can data be protected from unauthorized viewers? Data is encrypted prior to being transmitted and decrypted upon arrival at its destination." This reference clarifies that the pattern's purpose is to protect data from being viewed, which is not the issue described in the scenario, as the data is non-confidential.

2. Arcitura Education Inc. (2017). S90.09: Advanced SOA Security Course Booklet.

Module 3: Fundamental Security Patterns: This module details the problem and solution for each fundamental security pattern. The description for Direct Authentication focuses on validating a consumer's claimed identity. The description for Data Confidentiality focuses on using encryption to protect the secrecy of the message payload. The course material emphasizes applying the correct pattern to the corresponding problem. Applying a confidentiality pattern to a non-confidentiality problem would be considered an incorrect application.

Scroll to Top