8020 practice question 12 of 15

For credit risk losses containing operational risk elements that have been historically included in an organizations' credit risk database how should the loss amount be treated?

Full set: 60 questions
Answer options
A: The entire loss amount is treated as credit risk
B: The entire loss amount is treated as operational risk.
C: The loss amount is split into credit and operational risk components.
D: The entire loss amount is treated as credit risk, but the loss is entered as a memorandum within the operational loss database and not used for capital modeling purposes. Correct answer
Correct Answer:
D. The entire loss amount is treated as credit risk, but the loss is entered as a memorandum within the operational loss database and not used for capital modeling purposes.
Explanation

According to the Basel Committee on Banking Supervision (BCBS) guidelines, which form the foundation for PRMIA's curriculum on this topic, losses with characteristics of both credit and operational risk should be treated under a single risk category for regulatory capital purposes to avoid double-counting. When an operational failure (e.g., failure to perfect collateral) causes or exacerbates a credit loss, the entire loss amount is allocated to the credit risk category for capital calculation. However, to ensure the operational failure is captured for internal risk management and process improvement, the event should also be recorded in the operational risk database on a memorandum basis, meaning it is not used in the operational risk capital model.

Why Incorrect

A. The entire loss amount is treated as credit risk: This is incomplete. While correct for capital allocation, it ignores the critical step of recording the operational failure for internal risk management purposes.
B. The entire loss amount is treated as operational risk: This is incorrect. The primary driver is a credit event (default), so regulatory guidance mandates treatment as credit risk.
C. The loss amount is split into credit and operational risk components: This is incorrect for regulatory capital purposes. The Basel framework explicitly directs firms to allocate the entire loss to a single category (credit, in this case) to ensure consistency and prevent capital arbitrage.

References

1. Basel Committee on Banking Supervision (BCBS). (2011

June). Operational Risk - Supervisory Guidelines for the Advanced Measurement Approaches. Bank for International Settlements. In Annex 2

"Guidance on loss data collection exercises

" Paragraph 10 states

"Losses related to credit risk are not subject to the operational risk capital charge. Any losses that have characteristics of both credit risk and operational risk should be categorised as credit risk for the purpose of calculating regulatory capital." Paragraph 11 clarifies that for internal purposes

banks may identify the operational risk components. This supports allocating the capital treatment to credit risk (Option D) while capturing the event for operational risk management. (Available at: https://www.bis.org/publ/bcbs196.pdf

Page 21).

2. Cruz

M. G. (2015). The PRMIA Handbook on Operational Risk: A Guide for Financial Services and Other Industries. PRMIA. Chapter 4

"OpRisk Data and Governance

" discusses boundary issues

aligning with the BCBS principle that credit-related operational losses are typically booked as credit losses for capital adequacy

while the operational element is tracked for management information.

3. Chernobai

A.

Rachev

S. T.

& Fabozzi

F. J. (2007). Operational Risk: A Guide to Basel II Capital Requirements

Models

and Analysis. John Wiley & Sons. In Chapter 3

"Operational Risk Management: Loss Data Collection

" the authors discuss the Basel II boundary rules

noting that losses from events like collateral management failures are treated as credit risk

even though they are caused by operational errors. This confirms the principle behind option D. (See Section 3.2.3

"Boundary between Credit and Operational Risks").

Scroll to Top