8020 practice question 13 of 15

For the National Australia Bank - FX Options case study, which was the major cause of the loss event?

Full set: 60 questions

Domain Risk Identification and Assessment

Answer options
A: Currency traders were allowed access to the risk system by the CEO.
B: Currency traders concealed losses using back office knowledge.
C: Currency traders smoothed profits and concealed losses. Correct answer
D: Currency traders were able to complete a Management Buy Out (MBO).
Correct Answer:
C. Currency traders smoothed profits and concealed losses.
Explanation

The major cause of the National Australia Bank (NAB) loss event in 2004 was the systematic practice by a team of four currency options traders of smoothing their reported profits and actively concealing mounting losses. This behavior began as an effort to manage earnings volatility to secure bonuses but escalated into outright fraud. The traders entered fictitious transactions into the system to hide their true, unsuccessful trading positions. This concealment allowed the losses to grow to approximately A$360 million before being discovered, representing a catastrophic failure of internal controls and risk oversight.

Why Incorrect

A. Currency traders were allowed access to the risk system by the CEO. This is factually incorrect. The issue was a breakdown in existing controls and segregation of duties, not a direct authorization from the CEO.
B. Currency traders concealed losses using back office knowledge. While they did exploit weaknesses in back-office processes, this was the method of concealment, not the primary cause. The fundamental cause was the decision to conceal losses and smooth profits.
D. Currency traders were able to complete a Management Buy Out (MBO). This is irrelevant. A Management Buy Out is a corporate finance transaction and has no connection to the NAB FX options trading fraud case.

References

1. Australian Prudential Regulation Authority (APRA). (2004). Report of the Investigation into National Australia Bank Limited's Currency Options Trading.

Section 1.3

Summary of Findings

page 2: "The investigation found that between October 2003 and January 2004

the traders entered into fictitious transactions in NAB’s financial recording systems with the objective of concealing and deferring trading losses that had been incurred on the currency options desk." This directly supports the concealment of losses.

2. Gandevani

S.

& O'Brien

M. (2005). An analysis of the NAB rogue trading scandal. Department of Finance

The University of Melbourne

Working Paper.

Page 4

Section 2.1: The paper discusses the traders' motivation

stating

"The traders' initial motivation was to smooth profits to ensure their bonuses... This escalated into hiding losses through fictitious trades when their trading strategies failed." This confirms the "profit smoothing and loss concealment" aspect.

3. Moosa

I. A. (2009). Operational Risk Management. Palgrave Macmillan.

Chapter 2

Case Studies of Operational Loss Events

Section on National Australia Bank (2004): This academic textbook analyzes the case

highlighting that "the traders concealed losses by entering false trades into the system... The initial motive was profit smoothing to guarantee bonuses

which subsequently turned into hiding losses." This corroborates that the core issue was the act of smoothing and concealment.

Scroll to Top