8020 practice question 14 of 15

For the TSB case what was the cause of the outage at the heart of the case?

Full set: 60 questions

Domain Risk Identification and Assessment

Answer options
A: A liquidity squeeze by a major hedge-fund via margin calls on trading positions resulted in the collapse of their website.
B: Sub-standard risk pricing and risk management left millions of people locked out of their accounts for weeks.
C: A failed attempts to move customers to a new IT system left millions of people locked out of their accounts for weeks. Correct answer
D: Their IT models did not work if prices were discontinuous.
Correct Answer:
C. A failed attempts to move customers to a new IT system left millions of people locked out of their accounts for weeks.
Explanation

The core cause of the TSB outage in April 2018 was a severely flawed IT migration project. TSB attempted to move its customer data and services from the platform of its former parent, Lloyds Banking Group, to a new system, Proteo, managed by its new owner, Sabadell. The new platform was not ready for the migration, suffering from inadequate testing and a lack of capacity to handle the volume of TSB's customers. This technical failure directly resulted in a prolonged outage, locking millions of customers out of their accounts and causing widespread service disruption, a classic and significant operational risk event.

Why Incorrect

A. This describes a liquidity or market risk event. The TSB crisis was an operational and IT risk failure, not a liquidity squeeze caused by a hedge fund.
B. While poor risk management was a fundamental issue, "sub-standard risk pricing" was not the direct cause. The proximate cause was the technical failure of the IT platform migration.
D. This refers to model risk, specifically related to financial models handling price jumps. This is irrelevant to the failure of a retail bank's core IT and online banking platform.

References

1. Financial Conduct Authority (FCA). (2022, December 20). Final Notice to TSB Bank plc. Section 4, Summary of Facts, Paragraph 4.2 states: "In April 2018, TSB updated its IT systems and migrated the data for its corporate and customer services onto a new IT platform. While the data itself migrated successfully, the platform immediately experienced technical failures. This resulted in a significant number of TSB’s 5.2 million customers being unable to access banking services."

2. Slaughter and May. (2019, November). Report on the TSB IT Migration Incident. Executive Summary, Page 1, Paragraph 1: "The issues which arose following the Migration were a result of the new platform (the Proteo Platform) not being ready to receive the volume of TSB customers and their data. This was due to a number of failings in the configuration, coding and capacity of the Proteo Platform..."

3. House of Commons Treasury Committee. (2019, June). IT failures in the financial services sector: Eleventh Report of Session 2017–19. HC 915. Chapter 3, Paragraph 58: "The proximate cause of the TSB failure was the decision to proceed with the migration before the new platform, Proteo, had been sufficiently tested."

Scroll to Top