CIMAPRA19-E02-1 practice question 10 of 30

An employee of a company has been asked to explain the difference between a Grievance and Disciplinary Action. The employee knows the definitions of…

Full set: 210 questions
An employee of a company has been asked to explain the difference between a Grievance and Disciplinary Action. The employee knows the definitions of both and, whilst they have two examples of actions which would result in Disciplinary Action, they can only think of one circumstance which may result in a Grievance, and this is Discrimination. Which of the following could the employee use as an additional example of a Grievance?
Answer options
A: The employee is regularly absent.
B: The employee feels that they have not been considered for promotion because of their age.
C: The employee entered a restricted area.
D: The employee feels that they have been given an unfair appraisal. Correct answer
Correct Answer:
D. The employee feels that they have been given an unfair appraisal.
Explanation

A grievance is a complaint raised by an employee against their employer regarding an aspect of their employment where they feel they have been treated unfairly. An unfair appraisal is a prime example of a situation that could lead to a grievance, as it concerns the employer's formal assessment of the employee's performance, which the employee believes to be unjust. This is distinct from disciplinary action, which is initiated by the employer in response to employee misconduct.

Why Incorrect

A. The employee is regularly absent: This is a potential misconduct issue for which the employer would initiate disciplinary action against the employee.
B. The employee feels that they have not been considered for promotion because of their age: This is a form of discrimination, which is an example the employee already identified, making it less suitable as an additional example.
C. The employee entered a restricted area: This is a breach of company rules and safety protocols, which would be grounds for disciplinary action by the employer.

References

1. CIMA. (2019). CIMA E2 Managing Performance Study Text. Kaplan Publishing UK. Chapter 10, Section 4, "Grievance and discipline," distinguishes between grievances (employee complaints) and disciplinary procedures (employer actions).

2. Armstrong, M., & Taylor, S. (2020). Armstrong's Handbook of Human Resource Management Practice (15th ed.). Kogan Page. Chapter 35, "Grievance and dispute resolution," outlines typical grounds for employee grievances, including unfair treatment in performance appraisals.

3. ACAS. (2022). Code of Practice on Disciplinary and Grievance Procedures. Advisory, Conciliation and Arbitration Service (UK). Paragraphs 41-47 detail the nature of grievances, citing issues like terms and conditions, health and safety, and new working practices as examples.

Scroll to Top