CIPP-A practice question 9 of 15

In which of the following cases would a Singaporean be prevented from accessing information about herself from an organization?

Full set: 90 questions
Answer options
A: The information was collected in the previous 12 months.
B: The information is related to an individual's credit rating. Correct answer
C: The cost of providing the information proved to be unreasonable.
D: Any personal information about others has been deleted from the document.
Correct Answer:
B. The information is related to an individual's credit rating.
Explanation

The Singapore Personal Data Protection Act (PDPA) 2012 grants individuals the right to access their personal data held by an organization. However, this right is not absolute and is subject to specific exceptions outlined in the Fifth Schedule of the Act. One such exception is for "opinion data kept solely for an evaluative purpose." Information related to an individual's credit rating is considered opinion data used for the evaluative purpose of determining creditworthiness. Therefore, an organization can legally deny an individual's request to access this specific type of information under the PDPA.

Why Incorrect

A. The information was collected in the previous 12 months. This timeframe relates to an individual's right to request information about how their data was used or disclosed, not a reason to deny access to the data itself.
C. The cost of providing the information proved to be unreasonable. The PDPA allows organizations to charge a reasonable fee for access requests, but an unreasonable cost is not a listed statutory exception for denying access to the information.
D. Any personal information about others has been deleted from the document. This is a required action to fulfill an access request while protecting the privacy of other individuals, not a reason to prevent access for the requester.

References

1. Personal Data Protection Act 2012 (No. 26 of 2012), Singapore Statutes Online (2020 Rev Ed).

Section 21(3): Specifies that an organisation is not required to provide an individual with his or her personal data or other information in respect of the matters specified in the Fifth Schedule.

Fifth Schedule, Part 1, Paragraph 1(c): Explicitly lists "opinion data kept solely for an evaluative purpose" as a category of personal data to which the access requirement does not apply.

2. Personal Data Protection Commission (PDPC) Singapore, "Advisory Guidelines on the PDPA for Selected Topics" (24 May 2021).

Chapter 3, Paragraph 3.30: Discusses the exception for "Opinion data kept solely for an evaluative purpose," providing examples such as performance appraisals and references. Credit rating information is a clear example of data used for an evaluative purpose.

Chapter 3, Paragraph 3.19: Clarifies that while organizations can charge a reasonable fee for access, the fee should not be used to prevent individuals from making access requests.

3. Chan, C. (2016). The Development of the Personal Data Protection Act in Singapore. Singapore Academy of Law Journal, 28, 864-901.

Page 883, Section C(1): Discusses the right of access under the PDPA and its limitations, noting the exceptions in the Fifth Schedule, including evaluative data, which aligns with the rationale for denying access to credit rating information.

Scroll to Top