CIPP-A practice question 10 of 15

SCENARIO – Please use the following to answer the next QUESTION: Bharat Medicals is an established retail chain selling medical goods, with a…

Full set: 90 questions
SCENARIO – Please use the following to answer the next QUESTION: Bharat Medicals is an established retail chain selling medical goods, with a presence in a number of cities throughout Indi a. Their strategic partnership with major hospitals in these cities helped them capture an impressive market share over the years. However, with lifestyle and demographic shifts in India, the company saw a huge opportunity in door-to-door delivery of essential medical products. The need for such a service was confirmed by an independent consumer survey the firm conducted recently. The company has launched their e-commerce platform in three metro cities, and plans to expand to the rest of the country in the future. Consumers need to register on the company website before they can make purchases. They are required to enter details such as name, age, address, telephone number, sex, date of birth and nationality – information that is stored on the company's servers. (Consumers also have the option of keeping their credit card number on file, so that it does not have to be entered every time they make payment.) If ordered items require a prescription, that authorization needs to be uploaded as well. The privacy notice explicitly requires that the consumer confirm that he or she is either the patient or has consent of the patient for uploading the health information. After creating a unique user ID and password, the consumer's registration will be confirmed through a text message sent to their listed mobile number. To remain focused on their core business, Bharat outsourced the packaging, product dispatch and delivery activities to a third party firm, Maurya Logistics Ltd., with which it has a contractual agreement. It shares with Maurya Logistics the consumer name, address and other product-related details at the time of every purchase. If consumers underwent medical treatment at one of the partner hospitals and consented to having their data transferred, their order requirement will be sent to their Bharat Medicals account directly, thereby doing away with the need to manually place an order for the medications. Bharat Medicals takes regulatory compliance seriously; to ensure data privacy, it displays a privacy notice at the time of registration, and includes all the information that it collects. At this stage of their business, the company plans to store consumer information indefinitely, since the percentage of repeat customers and the frequency of orders per customer is still uncertain. If a patient withdraws consent provided to one of the partner hospitals regarding the transfer of their data, which of the following would be true?
Answer options
A: The patient cannot purchase medications from Bharat Medicals.
B: The hospital has the right to refuse withdrawal of consent since it has a partnership with Bharat Medicals.
C: The hospital will obtain the necessary medications from Bharat Medicals and provide them directly to patient.
D: The patient can buy medications from Bharat Medicals by uploading prescription to the Bharat Medicals website. Correct answer
Correct Answer:
D. The patient can buy medications from Bharat Medicals by uploading prescription to the Bharat Medicals website.
Explanation

The withdrawal of consent pertains specifically to the automated transfer of data from the partner hospital to Bharat Medicals. This action only terminates that particular data flow. It does not affect the patient's ability to interact with Bharat Medicals as a direct consumer. The scenario explicitly states that any consumer can register on the website, place an order, and upload a prescription. Therefore, the patient can still purchase medications through this standard, manual process.

Why Incorrect

A. Withdrawing consent for a specific data sharing arrangement does not prohibit the individual from engaging in a separate, direct transaction with the company.
B. The right to withdraw consent is a fundamental principle of data privacy. A commercial partnership between two entities cannot override an individual's right to control their personal data.
C. The scenario describes a data transfer for automated ordering, not a service where the hospital procures and delivers medications on behalf of the patient.

References

1. The Digital Personal Data Protection Act, 2023 (India): Section 6(4) states, "The data principal shall have the right to withdraw her consent at any time... The withdrawal of consent shall not affect the lawfulness of processing of personal data based on consent before its withdrawal." This establishes the patient's right to withdraw consent (refuting B) and implies that other lawful processing, such as a direct purchase, can continue (supporting D).

Source: The Digital Personal Data Protection Act, 2023, Act No. 22 of 2023, Parliament of India.

2. Academic Analysis of Consent under Indian Law: "Consent is the cornerstone of the [DPDP] Act... The Act also grants data principals the right to withdraw their consent at any point in time." This principle confirms that consent is not irrevocable and a business partnership cannot negate this right. The withdrawal for one purpose does not invalidate all interactions.

Source: Saraf, S., & Singh, A. (2023). India's Digital Personal Data Protection Act, 2023: A Primer. Carnegie Endowment for International Peace. Page 3.

3. Principle of Purpose Limitation: Data protection frameworks globally, including the principles influencing India's DPDPA, operate on purpose limitation. The consent for hospital-to-Bharat transfer is for a specific purpose (automated ordering). Withdrawing it only affects that purpose. The separate purpose of a direct customer purchase, initiated by the patient, remains a valid and available processing activity.

Source: S.K. Verma & Raman Mittal (Eds.), Intellectual Property and Private International Law (2021). Indian Law Institute. (Discussion on data protection principles in the Indian context). Chapter on Data Protection, Section on Purpose Limitation.

Scroll to Top