ICYB practice question 17 of 25

Training cost is $3,000 and a project required an initial investment of $12,000. If the project yields monthly savings of $1,800 beginning after 3 months, what is the payback period in months (before money costs and taxes)?

Full set: 120 questions
Answer options
A: 4.17
B: 8.33
C: 11.33 Correct answer
D: 28.28
Correct Answer:
C. 11.33
Explanation

The payback period is the total time required to recover the initial investment. The total initial investment includes all upfront costs, which are the project investment and the training cost ($12,000 + $3,000 = $15,000). The time needed to recoup this amount from the monthly savings is calculated as $15,000 / $1,800 per month, which equals 8.33 months. However, the problem states that these savings only begin after an initial 3-month period. Therefore, this 3-month delay must be added to the recovery time. The total payback period is 3 months + 8.33 months = 11.33 months.

Why Incorrect

A. 4.17: This result is based on an incorrect calculation and does not logically follow the standard formula for the payback period with the given values.
B. 8.33: This figure correctly calculates the time to recover the total investment but omits the crucial 3-month delay before any savings are generated.
D. 28.28: This value is a significant miscalculation and does not represent the payback period based on the provided financial data.

References

1. Gitman, L. J., Zutter, C. J., & Smart, S. B. (2018). Principles of Managerial Finance (15th ed.). Pearson. In Chapter 9, "Capital Budgeting Techniques," the payback period is defined as the time required for an organization to recover its initial investment in a project. The calculation involves summing cash inflows over time until they equal the initial outlay, which inherently includes any initial periods with zero inflow.

2. Brigham, E. F., & Ehrhardt, M. C. (2016). Financial Management: Theory and Practice (15th ed.). Cengage Learning. Chapter 11, "Cash Flow Estimation and Risk Analysis," explains that the initial investment outlay (at time t=0) must include all costs required to get the project operational, such as installation and training. The payback period calculation then tracks the time until cumulative net cash flows recover this total initial outlay.

3. MIT OpenCourseWare. (2008). 15.401 Finance Theory I, Lecture Notes. Massachusetts Institute of Technology. Lecture 3, "Capital Budgeting," defines the payback period as the time until the initial investment is recovered. The timeline for this calculation begins at t=0, meaning any delay before positive cash flows begin is part of the total period.

Scroll to Top