LEED-AP-BDC practice question 7 of 35

What type of project would benefit from showing compliance with Energy and Atmosphere Prerequisite, Minimum Energy Performance, Option 2. Prescriptive Compliance: ASHRAE 50% Advanced Energy Design Guide?

Full set: 305 questions
Answer options
A: One in which the budget and timeline would benefit from simplified decision making and analysis during the project design Correct answer
B: One in which the project team wants to explore the energy performance and load reduction effects of several envelope and lighting designs and mechanical systems
C: One in which the project team wants to achieve efficiency trade-offs between systems, offsetting the lower efficiency of one system by the improved efficiency of another One in which the owner wants an estimate of the carbon reductions or lower operating costs (energy savings, demand charge savings) from energy strategies, beyond a simple calculation for individual energy conservation measures
Correct Answer:
A. One in which the budget and timeline would benefit from simplified decision making and analysis during the project design
Explanation

The ASHRAE 50% Advanced Energy Design Guide provides a prescriptive compliance path. This path is designed for smaller, less complex projects (typically under 100,000 sq. ft.) and simplifies compliance by providing a pre-defined set of energy-saving measures. It avoids the time and cost associated with complex energy modeling, making it ideal for projects where the budget and timeline benefit from straightforward decision-making. This approach offers a streamlined alternative to the more intensive whole-building energy simulation (performance path).

Why Incorrect

B. Exploring multiple design options is the primary purpose of the performance path (Option 1, Energy Simulation), not the prescriptive path.
C. Trading off efficiencies between systems is a key feature of the performance path (energy modeling), which is explicitly not allowed in a prescriptive path.
D. Estimating carbon reductions and detailed operating costs requires a full energy simulation (performance path), which provides more granular data than a prescriptive checklist.

References

1. U.S. Green Building Council. (2019). LEED BD+C: New Construction v4 Reference Guide. Washington, DC: U.S. Green Building Council. p. 388, "EA Prerequisite Minimum Energy Performance, Option 2. Prescriptive Compliance."

2. ASHRAE. (2011). Advanced Energy Design Guide for Small to Medium Office Buildings: Achieving 50% Energy Savings. p. ix, "Introduction." The guide states its purpose is to provide a "prescriptive approach" to achieve significant energy savings.

Scroll to Top